This whole situation with students cheering and booing is kind of strange.
Aren't students, at least anecdotally, outsourcing a lot of _their_ work to LLMs? And upon graduation when they're told that it's their future they don't like it?
I described a bit of this in reply to thinkingemote, but to:
> And upon graduation when they're told that it's their future they don't like it?
They aren't being told it's their future. They're being told they have no future because AI will remove the world's dependence on them (well, the professional side of it at least).
Seems more like the issue is nuance and consideration or not. One side is saying that it is possible to do things that have value using LLMs. The other side is pointing out that this technology has increasing costs, is requiring data centers that have strongly negative environmental, social, and economic impacts, is promoting rampant, industrialized theft of intellectual property, is inserting errors, hallucinations, and psychotic ideas into all usage, and is at a number of levels doing damage to kids, elders, and professionals who are exposed.
If they did use it then maybe in hindsight they regret it, realize they didn't learn much, realize the temptation to cheat yourself will always be there and that's not a good thing.
Thanks for sharing this!
I'm also looking for an alternative to the official app, since having to log in with an account and accepting a privacy policy every time I want to change the time on my watch is pretty ridiculous – unfortunately I think this doesn't quite fit my use case as usually I'll want to sync the time when I go to a different country, and I'll normally only have my iPhone with me, which won't support WebBluetooth.
But this tool might be a starting point to fork and build a capacitor app with that can run on the phone I suppose.
You linked to the Android app there, not the experimental webapp linked above – I'm wondering what gave you that idea though?
Those commit messages look pretty human to me, don't think an LLM would ever just commit 'WIP' or 'code cleanup', it's also 4 years old, before the height of vibe coding.
I can imagine the author may have used an LLM for this webapp version of it though
Thanks for the link! Atuin is a powerful tool, especially with their focus on command management and execution.
From my perspective, the main difference is the UI footprint and the intended use case. Sklad is intentionally 'passive' and limited to the system tray. It’s not meant to be a full window or a command runner/executor. I built it as a simple warehouse for static data — like passwords, specific IPs, or boilerplate templates — that I need to grab quickly and paste anywhere, whether it’s a terminal, a browser, or a GUI prompt.
I also focused heavily on the recursive folder hierarchy within the native tray menu itself to help with mental mapping, whereas Atuin (and its UI) feels more search-centric and terminal-focused. I think there’s definitely room for both depending on whether you need to execute a command or just grab a piece of secure data.
Aren't students, at least anecdotally, outsourcing a lot of _their_ work to LLMs? And upon graduation when they're told that it's their future they don't like it?
reply