Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> "When that happens, the N.S.A. -- said to be the largest employer in Maryland -- goes belly-up. A way to prevent this is to expand its mission

The article is from 1994 and I believe my reaction is as true then as now.

Why can't NSA just switch to doing 90% information-assurance and work to secure US infrastructure?

Certainly there is more than enough work to go around, if they are looking for something to do I have some suggestions. The US military isn't really known for having secure communications or storage systems, maybe NSA should try to solve that problem (as a plus it is already part of their mission).

Is the claim here that NSA's budget would shrink if all they were doing was securing US systems and communications against foreign intelligence agencies? Does Congress consider that task unimportant?



I'm pretty sure they're focused on stopping terrorist attacks like 9/11 from happening.

Note that the NSA is not asking for Apple to give them a special key to the iPhone. The FBI is asking for it.

Note that a former NSA director (Hayden) and CIA director (Woolsey) have said they both support Apple in this case.


I'm reacting to a statement from 1994 in which it was claimed that the NSA wanted to expand its mission to ensure it could still employ the same number of people.

>I'm pretty sure they're focused on stopping terrorist attacks like 9/11 from happening.

That was not NSA's original mission and if congressional testimony is to be believed, not one NSA is particularly well suited to do. SIGINT/COMINT targeting the organs of the Soviet Union is a very different game than interrupting a terrorist plot by a small number of unknown actors.

>Note that a former NSA director (Hayden) and CIA director (Woolsey) have said they both support Apple in this case.

The FBI's position is so unreasonable that it appears nearly everyone that is well informed about the issue and isn't currently employed by the US government supports Apple, but we are talking about the Clipper Chip which was an NSA program.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: