Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Sure, but it's not a singular shadowy cabal in a star chamber. There are different groups who all have an negative impact on our lives.

The banal and stupid: Elon Musk and his fellow trust fund buddies and VCs doing jello shots and going "Antifa sucks amirite?" and acting on their stupidity because they have money and power.

Banal and stupid category 2: CEO groupthink. Let's all have layoffs before there's an actual recession because activist stockholders demand it and we don't have the guts to propose something better.

Then there's the John Birch Societies of the world: the actual organized shadow political movements. The Koch brothers using massive corporate profits to fund the right wing think tanks over multiple decades. They don't take credit, but the ascent of the right wing crazies is entirely down to them and fellow travelers.

Banal and stupid category 3: the people attending the WEF/Davos. enough said.

etc. you can probably list your favorites here, and you might slice them differently than I have. What there isn't is a single central group making decisions for the rest of us, nor is there any organized left-wing cabal. If you do think there's any kind of organized left-wing group of any sort in America, I'd love to know about it, because I'd like to join that group and I've never seen one in 20 years of looking.



If you study system theory you'll understand that a bunch of seemingly self-motivated actors without a central leader can achieve a system-wide outcome. A ant colony might be a simple example of this.


> If you do think there's any kind of organized left-wing group of any sort in America

I’m neither American, nor was talking about “left wing” American cabals that control the world.

I’m not sure why this has to be a singular group. It’s a tale as old as time, rich vs poor. One can clearly observe multiple not-necessarily-colluding but powerful groups globally and locally, who all aim to control and subjugate the rest of us.

This makes no sense to be a semantic debate where you grind an axe that “there is not just one illuminati” and act like that means something impressive.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: