Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The ban on single use plastic bags ignores the reality, which is that people often didn't plan to go to the shop or didn't plan to buy that much and so find themselves in need of a bag at the till.

I think it would be more pragmatic to have environmentally friendly single use bags available for a fee rather than wasting all those "reusable" bags.



I agree with your point. I saw a comment above they "solved?" this in some Scandenvian country by mandating the bags cost a ~$1 each. Not sure if that's high enough but I guess the point would be if you make the cost high enough people will quickly learn to bring their own bags.

I admit I am terrible at it. If I ride my bike then I bring something the carry the stuff home but if I take my car, even though I put bags in my trunk, it never even crosses my mind to use them :( Maybe posting this comment will help me remember next time.

On the other hand, my apartment complex demands we put our trash in plastic bags so I use the bags I get at the store for that ... sigh ...


Not sure if this helps, but I don't put bags in the trunk because yes, then it's super easy to forget them. I put them on the passenger seat.


People adapt though. I don't hear complaints about shopping bags anymore (except for American visitors), the way I still do about paper straws. Plastic bags at checkouts were only banned where I live a couple of years ago, and most people have learned to keep a few reusable bags in the car, and generally to plan better.

I actually worked in a hardware store for a while, and after the old supply of plastic bags ran out it was common practice for customers to either bring their own bags, carry stuff out in their hands, or use one of the hundreds of small cardboard boxes or trays that were set aside on receiving day when the shelves were stocked.


Well I am in Europe and people don't always drive everywhere.

I see it most days at the supermarket near my local train station: people get off the train and stop by to buy stuff. I see a good number of people buying "reusable" bags because they don't have any bags with them... it is ridiculous not to be able to have access to single use bags in this scenario. Mandate that they be paper or compostable if needed but "no it's banned" is not pragmatic at all.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: