Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A dog is personal property (possession) under the law. What is your point?


If you didn’t get my point the first time, I’m afraid you won’t get it.

Still, let’s give it a try.

I’m human, I do love my dog. I don’t consider it to be a table that has a 100€ price tag attached to it.

If someone stole my table, I’d be pretty pissed of because he stole me money.

If someone steal my dog, I’m pretty pissed off because I do LOVE it.

when I find my dog back, I’d be happy, not because I found back my 100€ worth of dog but because it’s a living being that I missed emotionally.

Hopefully you get the difference. I know some people who consider their animals like raw meat, 2€ a day worth of food + chained 24/24 to a tree = home guardian. I personally find that lunatic in 2026.

Think it’s a cultural thing. When I see how globally Americans treat their dog, and you’re right to point out it’s a property according to law, because that’s how they treat them. It’s like the dog is a table or a chair, and if you’re not happy with it you abandon it like you would throw away a broken chair.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: