Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

We had a similar problem with mobile search ads. The vast majority of clicks we got were misclicks, which is very painful when you're bidding $5+ click. We fixed the issue by putting a -90% bid on mobile ads. Now once every few months someone from Google calls us and tries to convince us to remove that -90% bid, assuring us the traffic is good and will convert. Pretty sleazy.


In our account penalizing the bid for mobile ads didn't help because it looks like Google treats 'mobile' and 'tablets' separately. So we prevented ads on phones, but you can't penalize the bid for tablets so that doesn't work to prevent games on iPads.

The Google support person told me they can't tell the difference between tablets and desktops, but I don't believe that for a second. Our own analytics clearly showed the user-agent for all of the visitors was for tablets and not desktops.


If you do not sell a mobile product you probably want to disable in app advertising.

I have found it brings nearly 0 conversions for regular websites.

To do this paste "adsenseformobileapps.com" in the “Placements” section of “Campaign Exclusions” from the Display Network tab.

More info on how to disable in app adwords advertising is here https://support.google.com/adwords/answer/1722057?hl=en


There is an option to exclude all in-app banner ads (I think).

It is experimental, and called "GMob mobile app non-interstitial", and it is under "Site Category Exclusions".

GMob - I think this is Google internal term for the AdMob business they bought

non-interstital - I think this is a fancy word for "banner" ads.

If you put it all together, excluding "GMob mobile app non-interstitial" as a Site Category, should stop your ads from running in mobile app banners.

If you do this when creating a campaign, then you can still target tablets without getting killed by flappy bird on the iPad.


The Google support person may not be fully informed, but they are provably incorrect in that claim.

Simply put, Google used to offer the ability to include/exclude devices based on desktop/tablet/mobile device types. Additionally, they offer the ability in their device segment reports in the AdWords UI to see what device did what. They have the data.

When Enhanced Campaigns were launched in the not so distant past, there was a large uproar from the paid search community (of which I consider myself apart of given my search agency background). It was very much a sense of them forcing mobile traffic despite our wishes and the negative bid modifier for mobile was something we had to push them on.

At the time, Google took the stance that tablet traffic/usage was largely indistinguishable from desktop traffic, so it shouldn't be a problem to blend those. Anyone with half a clue in this field could point out several reasons why that was false, but we were unsuccessful in getting that changed.

There have been a few changes to AdWords targeting and settings in the past couple of years that were pretty large steps back for savvy advertisers, and this was one of them.


Isn't it also the case that you can restrict your ads to Google search only which should avoid these in app ads? Or are you looking for placements on the display network as well (or only)?


This only applies to the display network. If you restrict to Search, you don't have to worry about game banners, or banner ads at all.


^^this.

awhile back, google decided it would be better to ram mobile traffic down your throat. ie when you buy from them mobile is included by default. thats not to say that mobile won't do well for you. you'd be best served to separate this. on the google content network you'd be better served to create specific placements instead of using keywords. especially in your case. you can get good traffic from the content network it just takes a bit of learning/tweaking.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: