Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The facts and figures generally don’t support the rose-tinted political view of work. Studies consistently show how jobs keep many of us poor while also making us ill, stressed, exhausted and demoralised

This whole article is a ridiculous strawman. People don't advocate hard work for its own sake (or if they do, this viewpoint isn't politically influential). They promote hard work for what it brings, that is, whatever the worker produced.

Graeber's essay is wrong. There are no "bullshit jobs". From the employer's point of view, why would they hire someone if hiring that person wasn't profitable? Does he really think businesses put the ideology of everyone having a job over profit?



I think if you graphed money and work you'd find some cycles that weren't really benefitting mankind. There's definitely work that is not needed.

Additionally plenty of people are not working 100% of the time at their job. Many Amazon Turks are these people. Either they have work they are procrastinating OR they don't have much to do.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: